This website was built with Leapd

Build yours freeYour site? Remove this notice

Comparison

TrustMyGuide vs TourTruth — The Best Platform for Aggregated Scottish Tour Guide Ratings

TourTruth tells you a tour scores 4.6. TrustMyGuide shows you who the guide is, where each rating came from, and how much evidence is behind it.

The honest version

TourTruth is the closest idea to ours, and it proves travellers want this. Many tours show near-perfect ratings, so it is hard to tell a strong experience from an inflated one. TourTruth responds by combining ratings from several big platforms into one normalised score, free to use, across a very wide range of cities. That scale is something we can't match, and we won't try to.

Where we differ is depth. TourTruth scores tours and activities across the world. TrustMyGuide scores Scottish guides and operators: the person leading your day, with a breakdown of where each rating came from.

Sample data notice: trust scores, reviews and guide examples shown across TrustMyGuide are illustrative sample data. Live feeds from TripAdvisor, Viator, GetYourGuide and Google are still being connected. TourTruth details here come from its public materials, are not independently verified and may change, so check TourTruth directly.

Side-by-side comparison

Scope

TourTruth

Broad and tour-centric. It describes itself as covering tens of thousands of tours across 120 cities (TourTruth’s own figures, which we have not verified).

TrustMyGuide

Scotland only. The directory, profiles and comparisons are built around Scottish guides and operators.

What is being scored

TourTruth

Tours and activities. A tour’s score can’t separate a great guide from a great itinerary.

TrustMyGuide

The named guide or operator, across their listings and platforms, so you can judge who you will spend the day with.

Scotland depth

TourTruth

Its public positioning is broad and US-city oriented. We found no clear evidence of Scotland-specific guide coverage, which is not proof there is none.

TrustMyGuide

Scottish guides and operators only, with Highland and ancestral-tourism specialisms in our directory.

Review sources

TourTruth

Combines ratings from Viator, Tripadvisor, GetYourGuide and Klook, plus other sources, into one normalised score, by its own description.

TrustMyGuide

Built to combine TripAdvisor, Viator, GetYourGuide and Google reviews. Live feeds are still being connected; current scores are sample data.

Scoring transparency

TourTruth

Describes normalisation, recency and suspicious-review filtering, but doesn’t publish weights or enough detail to reproduce a score.

TrustMyGuide

Shows a per-platform breakdown next to the composite. Our score weights each platform by a trust weight and by review count on a log scale. We plan to publish the full method.

Small samples

TourTruth

A provider can show a near-perfect score from a handful of reviews, which can look as authoritative as a large sample.

TrustMyGuide

We aim to show review counts and evidence strength beside every score, so 12 reviews never look like 640.

Operator tools

TourTruth

An aggregator only. As far as we can tell it has no operator submissions, first-party verification or guide replies.

TrustMyGuide

Claimed profiles, an operator dashboard with views, referral clicks and score trend, and booking links to the operator’s own page.

Cost to operators

TourTruth

Free to travellers. We have not verified how it earns, so check TourTruth directly.

TrustMyGuide

£29.99/month per listing card, first month free. The subscription buys a profile and analytics, never a higher score or ranking.

How TrustMyGuide is different

Guide-level, not tour-level

A normalised tour score tells you the itinerary is popular. A guide profile tells you who is leading it. We score the person across every listing and platform they appear on.

See where each rating came from

One number hides why ratings differ. Our profiles break the composite into its platforms, so you can see what sits behind it.

Scotland first

Going deep on one country means named guides, regional specialisms and ancestral-tourism experts rather than thin coverage of many cities.

No pay-to-rank

Guides pay a flat £29.99/month per card for a profile and analytics. Payment never changes a score or a ranking, and we take no booking commission.

A route for operators to engage

Guides can claim their profile, keep their details current and see how travellers find them. That first-party link is what a pure aggregator lacks.

Use both, not either/or

Use TourTruth for a quick cross-check of a tour's rating. Use TrustMyGuide to vet the Scottish guide behind it. Every profile links to the operator's own booking page.

Also comparing the marketplaces?

Read our Viator comparison and our GetYourGuide comparison.

When TourTruth is the better choice

  • You are comparing tours in many cities worldwide and want one normalised score for all of them.
  • You want a free tool that checks a tour’s rating across several large marketplaces at once.
  • You care about breadth of coverage more than depth in one country.
  • You are happy judging a tour listing rather than the individual guide.
  • You want to sanity-check an inflated near-5.0 marketplace rating against other sources.

If you are choosing a guide in Scotland and want to know who you are handing your day to, start with TrustMyGuide.

Frequently asked questions

What is TourTruth?

TourTruth is a review aggregator that combines ratings from large travel platforms into one normalised score for tours. The figures it quotes about its own coverage are its own claims, and we have not independently verified them.

Is TrustMyGuide the same as TourTruth?

They share the idea of combining ratings from several platforms. TourTruth is broad and tour-centric. TrustMyGuide is Scotland-first and guide-centric, with claimed operator profiles and a dashboard.

Does TrustMyGuide show live reviews today?

Not yet. The scores and reviews currently shown on TrustMyGuide are sample data used to demonstrate the profile format. Live platform feeds are still being connected, subject to each platform’s data terms, and we will say clearly when they are switched on.

Does paying for a listing change a guide’s score or ranking?

No. The £29.99/month listing buys a profile and analytics. It never changes the composite score or where a guide appears.

How much does it cost for a Scottish tour guide to list?

Each listing card costs £29.99 per month, and the first month is free. It is a flat rate per card with no commission on bookings.

Find a Scottish guide you can trust

Travellers: browse guides and compare trust scores. Guides: list your card for £29.99/month, first month free.

Built with Leapd